In most countries, fines are put in place as one of the instruments to limit the spread of the coronavirus. As the figure below shows, the penalties for violating social distancing rules differ widely between countries.
How do these amounts really affect one’s wallet? Bavarians and Greeks might both pay 150 €, their purchasing power is not equal. To make a more meaningful comparison, the fines have been adjusted based on Gross Domestic Product per capita for each country or region.
Now an entirely different picture emerges. Discrepancies remain, however. Penalties in Italy and Spain, both hit hard and early in the pandemic crisis, make a fine in Stuttgart look like a bargain.
Law enforcement differs greatly between countries as well. Through May 11th, police in England and Wales had handed out more than 14.000 fines. One day later, France announced a total of 1,1 million fines since the start of the corona measures. In a twist of irony, Mr Christophe Castaner, French Minister of Interior, praised his fellow countrymen for their sense of responsibility and good citizenship. 1,1 million: after all this was not even 6% on the total of 20,7 million controls carried out.
The figure below highlights these differences. All in all, the average Spaniard is bad off. Compared with a Dutchman, he is twenty times more likely to receive a fine, a fine which on top of that will be twice as salty.
In one area, European countries show remarkable uniformity though. Whatever the amount or the likelihood of a corona fine, complaints can be heard everywhere.
Regulations and fines are in Germany organized at the regional level, not at the federal level.
BW=Baden-Württemberg; NRW= North Rhine-Westphalia
For a given country X, the normalized fine equals:
Original Fine X * (GDP/capita Netherlands) / (GDP/capita X)
On Gross Domestic (Regional) Product
Germany – Baden-Württemberg, North Rhine-Westphalia, Bavaria: Statistische Ämter des Bundes und der Länder
Other countries: IMF World Economic Outlook Database
On population size
Germany – Baden-Württemberg, North Rhine-Westphalia, Bavaria: Statistisches Bundesamt
England, Wales: Office for National Statistics
Other countries: World Bank, via ECDC
On fine amounts
Albania: 10.000 ALL (80 €); Pedestrians violating lockdown restrictions; Exit News, 14/04/20
Belgium: 250 €; Private people violating lockdown rules; Médiation de Dettes, 07/05/20
France: 135 €; Private people violating lockdown rules; Franceinfo, 03/04/20
Germany, Bavaria: 150 €; Meeting in public space with unauthorized people; Bussgeldkatalog
Germany, Baden Württemberg: 100 €; Meeting in public space with unauthorized people; Bussgeldkatalog
Germany, North Rhine-Westphalia: 200 €; Public meeting with > 2 persons; Bussgeldkatalog
Greece: 150 €; Not wearing mask while using taxi or public transport; UNHCR, Greece
Italy: 400 €; Unauthorized movement outside the home; Il Sole 24 Ore, 26/03/20
Luxemburg: 500 €; Private people violating lockdown rules; RTL, 17.03.20
Netherlands: 390 €; Private people violating lockdown rules; Volkskrant, 28.05.20
Spain: 601 €; Unauthorized movement outside the home; The Local.es, 17/04/20
On number of fines
Albania – 17/04/20: 7343; Exit News, 11/05/20
Belgium – 07/05/20: 84.000; La Libre Belgique, 07/05/20
England – 11/05/20: 13.445; BBC News, 15/05/20
France – 12/05/20; 1.100.000; Les Echos, 12/05/20
Greece – 26/04/20; 53.009; The National Herald, 26/04/20
Netherlands – 10/05/20: 18.200; Nu.nl, 22/05/20
Spain – 20/05/20: 1.013.747; Diario AS, 20/05/20
Wales – 11/05/20: 799; BBC News, 15/05/20
Further reading (in Dutch):
Boetebeu, Reporters Online, 15/06/20
Hoe erg is het eigenlijk met die coronaboetes in Nederland?, Elsevier Weekblad, 11/06/20
One thought on “Fine differences”
Pingback: Fining the man at the top - The Corona Diaries
Comments are closed.